The Pros and Cons of Using a Dog Harness

21 April, 2023 | by Arrow T Pets

As a dog owner, you want to ensure your furry friend is safe, comfortable, and secure while walking or running around. The dog harness is one of the most important tools in your dog’s walking equipment. However, other options are also available, such as the dog choke chain and dog retractable leash.

Using a dog harness can have both pros and cons for dogs, depending on their individual needs and behavior. Some potential benefits of using a harness include: Reduced strain on the neck and spine and better control.

Dog Harness: Pros and Cons

A dog harness is a popular alternative to the traditional dog collar. It is designed to wrap around your dog’s body and distribute pressure evenly, making it a more comfortable and safer option for your dog.

Pros:

Improved control and safety during walks, especially for larger dogs or those who tend to pull
It can help prevent choking or injury to the neck or throat
Some harnesses are designed to support mobility and assist with training, such as the no-pull or service dog harnesses
It comes in a variety of styles and materials, allowing you to choose one that fits your dog’s specific needs and preferences
It may be better for dogs with respiratory or neck problems

Cons:

Some dogs may not like the feeling of a harness, particularly if they are not used to it
Certain types of harnesses may not be suitable for all dogs, depending on their size, shape, and level of activity
It may be more expensive than a traditional collar
Some harnesses may rub or cause discomfort if not fitted properly

Dog Choke Chain: Pros and Cons

A dog choke or slip chain is a type of collar that tightens when your dog pulls, causing discomfort or pain. While some dog owners still use choke chains for training or control purposes, they are generally considered outdated and potentially harmful to your dog.

Pros:

Can provide some level of control during walks or training sessions
It can be effective for certain types of dogs or behavioral issues when used properly

Cons:

Can cause physical pain, injury, or distress to your dog’s neck, throat, or trachea
This can lead to breathing difficulties, coughing, or gagging
Can promote aggressive or fearful behavior in some dogs
It can damage your dog’s coat, skin, or fur if not used correctly
It may not be legal or acceptable in certain areas or dog training facilities

Dog Retractable Leash: Pros and Cons

A dog retractable leash is a type of leash that allows your dog to roam further away from you while still attached to a cord or cable. Retractable leashes are popular among dog owners who want to give their dogs more freedom and flexibility during walks or runs.

Pros:

It can give your dog more space to explore and exercise
It can allow you to control the length of the leash, depending on the situation or environment
It can be helpful for dogs who have mobility issues or need extra support
It can be convenient and easy to use

Cons:

It can be dangerous or unpredictable if not appropriately used, especially near traffic, other animals, or people
It can be challenging to control or reel in if your dog is pulling or running too fast
It can cause injury or cuts to your dog’s skin, fur, or paws if the cord or cable gets tangled or caught on an object
It may not be suitable for all types of dogs or walks, depending on your dog’s size, behavior, or training level

Comfort and Fit

When choosing a dog harness, choke chain, or retractable leash, comfort and fit should be a top priority. You want to ensure your dog feels comfortable and the equipment fits properly to prevent any discomfort or injury. Each type of equipment has different considerations for comfort and fit.

Dog Harness:

Look for a harness that is adjustable and fits snugly but not too tight
Check that the harness doesn’t rub or chafe your dog’s skin or fur
Consider your dog’s mobility and any health issues when choosing a harness
Choose a material that is breathable and durable

Dog Choke Chain:

Ensure that the chain is the correct size for your dog, not too loose or tight
Avoid leaving the choke chain on for extended periods to prevent injury or discomfort
Do not use a choke chain on dogs with respiratory or neck problems
Never use a choke chain for punishment or negative reinforcement

Dog Retractable Leash:

Look for a leash that is appropriate for your dog’s weight and size
Check that the locking mechanism works properly to prevent accidents
Make sure the cord or cable doesn’t rub or tangle with your dog’s skin or fur
Consider the type of handle and grip for comfort and control

Safety

Safety is a crucial factor when it comes to choosing dog walking equipment. You want to ensure your dog is safe and secure while walking or running.

Dog Harness:

Provides improved control and safety during walks
It can prevent choking or injury to the neck or throat
Some harnesses have reflective materials for better visibility at night
Choose a harness with sturdy and durable materials

Dog Choke Chain:

Can cause physical pain, injury, or distress to your dog’s neck, throat, or trachea
This can lead to breathing difficulties, coughing, or gagging
Can promote aggressive or fearful behavior in some dogs
Avoid using a choke chain on puppies, small dogs, or dogs with neck or respiratory problems

Dog Retractable Leash:

It can be dangerous or unpredictable if not appropriately used, especially near traffic, other animals, or people
It can cause injury or cuts to your dog’s skin, fur, or paws if the cord or cable gets tangled or caught on an object
Do not use a retractable leash near busy roads, crowded areas, or unfamiliar places
Always keep your dog within sight and under control

Control and Training

One of the main reasons dog owners use walking equipment is to improve control and training. Each type of equipment has different advantages and disadvantages regarding control and training.

Dog Harness:

It provides better control and training than a traditional collar, especially for larger dogs or those who tend to pull
Some harnesses have no-pull or front-clip features that discourage pulling
Service dog harnesses can assist with mobility and training for specific tasks

Dog Choke Chain:

Can provide some level of control during walks or training sessions
It can be effective for certain types of dogs or behavioral issues when used properly
It can promote negative reinforcement and aggressive behavior in some dogs

Dog Retractable Leash:

It can give your dog more freedom to explore and exercise, but less control over you
It can be useful for basic obedience training, such as recall or sit commands
It can be challenging to control if your dog is pulling or running too fast

Mobility and Assistance

Some dogs may require additional support or assistance when walking or running. Each type of equipment has different features to support mobility and assistance.

Dog Harness:

Service dog harnesses can assist with mobility and training for specific tasks
Mobility harnesses can help dogs with arthritis or other mobility issues
Choose a harness with handles or straps for additional support and assistance

Dog Choke Chain:

Not suitable for dogs with mobility issues or respiratory problems

Dog Retractable Leash:

It can be useful for dogs who have mobility issues or need extra support
Look for a retractable leash with a comfortable handle and grip for support and control
Choose a leash with a sturdy and durable cord or cable to support your dog’s weight and movement

Behavior and Habituation

The type of walking equipment you choose can also affect your dog’s behavior and habituation. Each type of equipment has different advantages and disadvantages regarding behavior and habituation.

Dog Harness:

Can promote positive reinforcement and good behavior during walks
It may take some time for your dog to get used to wearing a harness, but it can be habituated with positive reinforcement

Dog Choke Chain:

It can promote negative reinforcement and aggressive behavior in some dogs
Should never be used for punishment or negative reinforcement
This may lead to fear, anxiety, or aggression in some dogs

Dog Retractable Leash:

It can encourage independence and exploration but may also promote pulling or bad behavior
It may take some time for your dog to get used to the retractable leash, but it can be habituated with positive reinforcement
It should never be used as a punishment or negative reinforcement

Style and Design

The style and design of your dog’s walking equipment can also be a factor when choosing the right equipment for your dog.

Dog Harness:

It comes in a variety of styles and materials, allowing you to choose one that fits your dog’s specific needs and preferences
It can be stylish, with different colors, patterns, and designs
Some harnesses have reflective materials for better visibility at night

Dog Choke Chain:

Typically has a simple and basic design, with metal links or chains
It may not have much variety in terms of style or design

Dog Retractable Leash:

It comes in a variety of colors, styles, and designs
It can be stylish, with different patterns and prints
Some retractable leashes have built-in flashlights, waste bag dispensers, or other features

Cost

Finally, the cost is a consideration when choosing your dog’s walking equipment. Each type of equipment has different price ranges and factors to consider.

Dog Harness:

It can be more expensive than a traditional collar, depending on the material and features
Some harnesses can be in the $20-$50 range, while others can cost over $100

Dog Choke Chain:

Generally less expensive than a harness, with a typical cost of $10-$20
It may require more frequent replacement due to wear and tear

Dog Retractable Leash:

It can range in price from $10-$50, depending on the brand, length, and features
Some high-end retractable leashes can cost over $100

Conclusion

Different options are available when choosing the right walking equipment for your furry friend, including the dog harness, dog choke chain, and dog retractable leash. Each type of equipment has pros and cons, and it’s important to consider your dog’s specific needs and preferences. While the dog harness provides improved control, safety, and comfort, the dog choke chain may cause physical pain, injury, or distress to your dog’s neck, throat, or trachea, and the dog retractable leash may be unpredictable and potentially dangerous if not used properly. Regardless of your chosen equipment, using it properly and training your dog with positive reinforcement is crucial. Doing so ensures that your furry friend enjoys safe, comfortable, and enjoyable walks with you.

Blog